From Christina, Child's Age 16 - 12/21/04 - IP#: 24.233.80.xxx  Click here to reply  
Hi guys, First off, Happy Holidays! Well my daughter lost 20 lbs and now weights 120. Yet she think she needs to shed 10 more to be at her "ideal weight". Shes 5'2'' and very muscular. IS 110 is an ideal weight or 120? Hope to hear from you all soon! God bless.
Reply from Kaileen, Child's Age 14 - 02/24/05  - IP#: 66.31.212.xxx
i think ur daughter is at a very ideal weight. she is 16, 5'2 & 120 lbs..that is a very good weight..if she loses anymore weight, that might not be good..especially if shes so muscular! i think shes perfect..just have her keep up with her good eating habits and maintain the weight..be supportive..my daughter is 14 5'2 and weighs 125 lbs and i found out that she was at her appropriate weight because she goes to the gym 4 times a week for 1-2 hours...so just keep supporting her..well im not goin to babble on..but congrats on having her achieve a 20 lb weight loss..GoD bLeSS..love kaileen

 
Reply from kathryn, Child's Age 17 - 02/22/05  - IP#: 84.160.134.xxx
if she is very muscular then her ideal weight might be higher. Muscle weighs more then fat, so if you have lots of muscle then you might be overweight on the scale, but no unhealthy. you should ask her doctor, he can tell whats muscle and whats fat!

 
Reply from cristina - 01/01/05  - IP#: 24.233.65.xxx
Thankyou very much! And thanks for the info on the yoyo dieting. I didn't know it could be a problem.

 
Reply from Catherine, Child's Age 15 - 01/01/05  - IP#: 24.19.141.xxx
Make sure you congradulate her, and tell her how proud you are of what she has accomplished, for her height, 110 would be fine, but it is what ever she feels comfortable at, and tell her that it is ok to stay betwwen 110 and 120. You should stay 5 to 10 pounds of her goal weight. Just so she doesnt yo yo diet, cause thats not good on the heart.